Apparatus for controlling electric motors



Aug. 19, 1930. B, wlARD APPARATUS FOR CONTROLLING ELECTRIC MOTORS Filed Sept. 8, 1927 2 Sheets-Sheet l Aug. 19, 1930.

J. B. WIARD APPARATUS FOR CONTROLLING ELECTRIC MOTORS Filed Sept. 8, 1927 2 Shoets-Sheet 2 Joi'azallwicu d Patented Au 19, 1930' JOHN .B. WIARD, F LYNN, MASSACHUSETTS PATENT- 0F Pica nrrami'rus roa coivrnonnme nnnc'rmc morons Application filed September This invention relates to apparatus for coordinately controlling the starting of different motors of a group so as to automatically prevent the operation of some one or more 1 5 motors, or of devices driven thereby, duri the period that one or more other motorsb? the group are being startedand broughtup to speed. a 3

The invention has advantageous application to instances where-the o eration of one motor may serve to impose a one or more other motors of the group, as, j for instance, the operation of a motor em ployed to' feed work or material to be acted upon by some instrumentality driven by a second or work motor where the operation of the feed motor is apt to impose an undue load on the work motor if not'deferred until the work motor has completed its starting cycle and been brought toa condition where it may assume -its normalloadn As a specific illustration of such a case there may be instanced the use of motors in a wood-working machine where one motor is employed for driving the feed mechanism and a number of other mo- -tors utilized for driving the cuttin devices which cut or shape the work when t e latter is fed within their working flange.

lhe invention is particularly advantageous in its application to instances where the startin'g of tlie motors is performed automatically through remote or indirect control, as through relay-actuated, ,electro-magnetic devices so arranged that when a push button or other primary starting switch is actuated, a starting connection to' a power line is automatically effected, which on the completion of the starting cycle is followed by the automatic change from a starting to a running connection, the completion of the starting cycle being marked b the lapse of a predetermined time or by t e reduction of the cur-' rent input to a normal value or some other factor evidencing the attainment of the mm ning condition. y

In such cases the functioning of an automatic starter for a work motor, after having once been initiated by the operator, is outside of his further control except as he may interrupt it, and in many cases. he has no means of oad or dutyon a, 1927. Serial lid 218,256.

knowing when the motor has completed its starting cycle and-is in readiness to assume its normal load. Danger therefore arises'of prematurely imposing a load on the work motor, particularly wherethere are a number of such work motors, as in the case of a woodworking machine, and where it is customaryto start them in rapid succession before starting the feed motor; In such cases the operator before one or more of the wor motors is in proper condition to take up its normal duty, thereby prematurel loading the work motors, with possible fai ure of the starting apparatus or more serious results. 5 It is desirable, therefore, in such cases that the operation of the feeding mechanism by which the load is imposed upon the work 'motor. or motors be automatically locked out until such motor or motors are ready to per- 1 7 form their normal continuous duty.

In theillustrative embodiment of the invention I have shown several work motors in a group provided .each with remotely or indirectly controlled i starting means designed to function automatically and-complete the starting cycle through the control of a primary starting switch, there being provided means which prevent the operation of an as sociated feed mechanism after the initiation of'the starting cycle of. any work motor and until such starting cycle has been completed. By this means not only are the work motors protected against premature loading but the starting ofthe entire group of motors can 85 be performed more smoothly and exp'edi-? tiously since the operative has automatic as surance a ainst the inadvertentpremature startin o the feed mechanism. Whifie the invention broadly may have application to instances where the feed mechanism itself is driven from a source of power other than that supplied by an individual feed motor, and to cases where an individual feed motor is employed to drive the, feed mechanism, but the starting of the latter is a subject to other th'an'indirect or remote control, the same is herein shown for illustrative puiiposes as embodied in a system where the ee motor is also subject to remote control, 130

tor is apt inadvertently to start the feed-mo- .g

the several work motors of the group being provided with automatic starting devices embodying each a magetically-controlled starting switch with starting resistances, which latter are automatically cut out while the motor is connected directly to the power circuit through a magnetically-actuated main switch after the lapse of a suitable time determined by a timing device. The automatic functioning of the timing device is herein also utilized to control the feed motor through its magnetically-actuated starting switch, so

that, after the initiation of the starting cycle of any work motor and until itscompletion,

, the primary starting switch for the feed motor is rendered ineffective to start the latter, and the feed motor, if already connected to the power circuit, is cut out of operation, the starting circuit for the feedmotor, however, being restored to its condition of effectiveness on the completion of the starting cycle of the last work motor which has been set into operation and has attained full speed. The various work motors are often of different sizes requiring different" periods of time to complete the starting cycle. The control herein provided, however, prevents the starting of the feed motor until all motors started have been brought to full speed irrespective of the order of startin The invention will e best understood by reference to the following description when.

taken in connection with the accompanying illustration of one specific embodimentthereof, while its scope will be more particularly pointed out in the appended claims.

In the drawings 1 I Fig. 1 is a diagrammatic representation of the circuiting arrangement for a group of refmotely'controlled work motors and an associated feed motor embodying one form of the invention, the controlling device being shown with the general circuiting arrangementadopted in p'ractice;'-

F ig.- 2 is a detail illustrating one of the timing devices employed for controlling a' feed motor starting circuit; and V Fig. 3 is a-diagram suited for more ready reference showing the controlling circuits arranged in simplified across-the line form with the controlling devices conventionally indicated by the same reference'characters as in F 1 and in the same functional relations 1p. Referring to the drawings (more particularly to "Fig. 1) and to the illustrative em bodiment of applicants invention, the same is shown as applied to the individual but coordinated control of a group of work motors M, M, etc., and the associated feed motor M, the latter being intended to drive the:

feed mechanism, as, for example, the feed mechanism of a wood-working machine for feeding material to the working instrume'ntalities, such'as cutterheads, the latter independently driven by the several work motors.

An obvious extension of the same system of control may be applied to any number of work motors. For simplification a group of two. work motors only is herein shown and the starting devices and connections for controlling one of such work motors only is illustrated in detail, the remaining work motor or motors being provided with starting devices and connections similar to the one illustrated in detail.

The three motors indicated in the drawing are of the three phase, squirrel cage induction type and are arranged to be operated from the main alternating-current power lines P, P P the work motors being proshown in heavy lines and, such connections being in the-usual conventional form, require no further description except as may be incidental to the explanation of the feed motor control.

The control circuits for the entire group of motors are herein shown subject to the control of a master relay switch and a master relay circuit, which latter must first be-closed to render the starting devices for the sevto maintain the line connections of the motors so that all motors of the group riay be simultaneously cut out of circuit through the master relay switch. 7 The power for operating the various relay circuits and master relay switch gis .taken from the main .power lines P and P Referring first'to the master relay switch and associated connections, the former comprises the switch contacts 11 and 12 normally held in open circuit position (full lines in Fig. 1) by a spring or gravity or both, but.

adapted to be thrown by the magnet 13 (dotted line position in Fig. 1) to engage contacts 14 and. 15 which are permanently connected to the poiverline I through the blow- I out coils 16, fuse 17 and conductor 18.

-The magnet 13 is controlled b primary switch means at the control pane comprising a starting push-button switch 19, normally in open circuit position, and a stop push-button switch 20 normally inclosed circuit position.

To close the master relay switch, which is .'.a necessary preliminary to starting any of the motors of the group, the starting pushbutton 19 is depressed, bridging the contacts 21 and 22. The contact 21 is permanently eral motors effective and must remain closed connected to the power line P through conductors 23 and 18 so that the actuation of the startlng push-button 19 energizes the master relay magnet 13 through a circuit compris-' ing the conductor 23, contact 21, button 19, a

30 and conductor 31 to power line P.

The overload switches 0,0, 0', O are normally closed, but are adapted to be opened to break the master relay c1rcu1t on sustained overload in the power circuits of any one of the severalJwork motors, beingsubject to the action of the magnet coils 32. contained in two of the three power circuits for each motor. Any suitable overload circuit breakers may be employed, there being herein shown a conventional representation of an overload e disclosed in Patent No. 1,584,063, dated May 11, 1926.

The momentary depression of the pushbutton 19 energizes the magnet 13 and closes the master switch, connecting the master relay circuit throu h the power lines P, and P, rendering it e ectiv'e for starting the several motors.

When the push-button 19 is released, the

' master relay circuit is maintained closed so long as the overload switches remain closed and the stop push-button 20 is undisturbed, the circuit being maintained from the power line P conductor 18, contact 15, switch contime, the master relay circuit is immediately opened, the power line P cut off from the imotor control devices, and all motors connected to the lines are immediately disconnected therefrom.\ v f The control connections for the feed motor M, except for the look-out control through 1 control.

the work motor starting devices, are in conventional form usual in systems of remote The feed motor control circuits ,Will first be described. v

For control of the feed motor there is provided a normally opened .main switch 34 ada ted to be thrown to a' closed position by t e magnet 35 to connect the 'powerlines to the motor fordirect drive, there being also provided a motor reverse switch 36 adapted to be thrown by the magnet 37 for connect ing the power lines to the motor for reverse drive.

To close the main or direct drive switch 34,

the normally open, starting push-button -38 at the control panel is momentarily depressed.

several work motors,

through the normally closed, sto

This bridges the contacts 39 and 40 and, providing that the starting devices for the work motors are not then functioning, connects the magnet 35 between the power lines P and P closing the switch 35 and starting the feed motor.

The circuit which is completed by depressing the push-button 38 is from the power line P through conductor 18, contact 14, switch contact 11, conductor 41, feed-motor-control circuit 42, thence through normally closed contacts 43 at each'of the timer switches T associated with the starting devices of the thence returning through circuit 44 to contact 45, through the normally closed, stop push-button 46, con

tact 47, conductor 48; contact 49, normally closed, reverse push-button 50, contact 51, conductor 52, contact 40, push-button 38, contact 39, conductors 53 and 54, through magnet coil 35, conductor 55, feed motor overload switches O, O, conductors 56, 28, 29 and 31 to power line P.

If any work motor is passing through its startin cycle when the push-button 38 is depressef, the described motor control circuit isopened at one of the timer switches T, as hereinafter explained, and the feed motor cannot be started, or, if any work motor is started during the operation of the feed motor, the control circuit is immediately opened by the timer switch T and this acts to deenergize the. main switch magnet 35 of the feed motor and stop the latter.

After the momentary depression of the push button 38 and the closure of the switch 34, the feed-motor, control circuit is mainductor 60 to the contact 59, through bridga ing switch 57, contact 58, thence through conductor 61 to conductor 54, and thence through the magnet coil 35 to the power line P, as heretofore described.

' Since the feed-motor, control circuit passes pushbutton 46, the circuit may be opene at any time and the feed mo'tor stopped by depress-. ing the stop push button,

Toreverse the feed motor, the reverse push button 50 is depressed to open the contacts '49and 51 and close the reverse contacts 62 and 63. This serves to break the circuit through the main switch magnet 35 and close the circuit through the reverse switch niagnet 37. When the reverse push-button 50 is depressed the motor control circuit extends, as

previously described, from the power line P through the timer switches T, back through the stop push-button 46 and conductor 48, but thence extends through the contact 62, push-button 50. iconact 68, conductor 64 to magnet coil 37 and thence through conductor back to the power line P, as previously described.-

Referring now to the work motors, each motor is provided with automatic starting elements including the starting switch 70 with its actuating magnet 71 adapted when energized to connect the motor to the power lines through suitable starting resistances R, there being also provided the main line I switch 72 with its controlling magnet 73 cable to systems of motor control employing other types of automatic starters, as where the current inrush at starting is regulated by other means, or where a change from a starting connection to a running connectionis controlled otherwise than by a timing element, the objectbroadly being that the feed its load.

mechanism or feed motor through some device responsive to the completion of the starting cycle of the work motor shouldbe rendered ineflective until the Work motor shall have completed its prescribed automatic starting cycle, however performed and measured, and is in a proper condition to assume Referring to the il'lustrative embodiment of the invention, to start a work; motor, as the motor M, the master switch 11, 12 having been previously closed as heretofore described, the corresponding startingpush 74 is depressed, bridging the contacts ,7 5 and 76. This closes a circuit through the magnet 71, throwing on the starting switch 70 and connecting the motor M' to the power lines through the resistances R and overload coils The magnet circuit thus closed leads from the power line P through the switch 11, conductors 41 and 77, contact 78, through the normally closed, stop push-button 79, contact 80, conductor 81, contact 75, starting l push-button 74, contact 7 6, conductors 82 and movable with and by 83 to magnet 71, and thence through conductors 84,85,29 and 31 back to. the power line P.

The actuation of the starting switch also actuates an associated bridging switch 86.

to bridge the stationary contacts 87 an 88,

the switch adaptedthereby establishing a circuit such that after the release of the starting push button 74 the work-motor-starting circuit is maintained for the duration of the starting cycle through the stop push button 79.

The latter circuit is from the power line P through push-button .7 9, as previously described, thence through the contact and conductor 81 to conductors 89, 90 to the conductor 91- flexibly coupled to the pivoted contact arm 92 at the main switch 72, the circuit extending therefrom through the stationary, contact 93, conductor 94, contact 87 at the switch 70, bridging switch 86, contact 88 and conductor 95 back to the conductor 83, through magnet coil 71 and back to the power line P, as previously described.

With the closing of the starting switch, the motor commences to accelerate with its current inrush limited by the resistances R and after the lapse of a suitable interval is brought to its normal speed and automatically connected tothe power line through the main switch 72. The actuation of the switch 72 is herein automatically controlled by the timing switch'T which comprises a bridging switch normally closing the contacts 43 in the feed-mot-or-control circuit but movable under the influence of the magnet 96 to break such control circuit immediately the starting button 74 is depressed and to maintain the circuit broken until after the starting cycle has been'completed-and .the inain starting switch 72 actuate d. The magnet 96'is connected in shunt about the starting switch magnet 71, one terminal being connected to conductor 82 by conductor 97 and its remaining terminal to conductor by conductor 98, so that, on the first initiation of the starting cycle by the depression of the button 74, the magnet 96 is energized and instantly breaks the feed-motor-control circuit, the circuit of the magnet 96 however, remaining established after the release of the start push-button by the same connections, heretofore described, in connection with the switch magnet 71, that'is to say, from power line 1? through switch 11, conductors 41 and 77, contact 78, push button 79, contact 80, conduc tors-81, 89, and 91, contact arm 92, contact 93,conductor 94, contact 87, bridging switch 86, contact 88, conductors and 97, magnet 96, conductors 98, 85 and 29 to power line I.

The timing switch T, with its control magnet, is so arranged that on energization-of the magnet the switch is given a substantially instantaneous movement, opening the feedmotor-control circuit. This is followed by a delayed or time-retarded movement which, after the lapse of a predetermined time, results in closing the circuit by which the actuation of the main switch 72 is effected, the switch then automatically returning to its initial position and again closing the feed motor control circuit. The timing switch thus times the functioning of the switches 71 and 72 and controls the duration of the starting cycle, and also acts responsively at the completion of the starting cycle to again render effective the feed-m0tor-control circuit which it had caused to open on the initiation of thestarting cycle. V g The general arrangement of the timing switch, conveniently shown in the diagram in Fig. 1, is illustrated in Fig. 2. As there shown, the magnet 96 is supported in the frame 99 and is provided with the vertically movable soft iron core 101, to theupper end of which is connected through the pin 102 the bridging switch T in the form of a metal- .lic disc. Below the frame 77 there depends a cup 103, which .contitutes adash pot cylinder. containing oil or other suitable liquid.

The lower end of the core is connected to a dashpot piston 104 through a lost motion connection comprising a cap 105, connected to the piston and the headed pin 106 vertically movablewithin the cap.

When the magnet 96 is deencrgized the pis- 3 ton 104rests-in the bottomof the cup, with the core in its lowered position and the disc T resting on the contacts 43, closing the feed-motor-control circuit. When the magnet is energized bythe depression of the starting button 74, the core is lifted'part way, almost instantaneously breaking the feedmotor-control-circuit at the contacts 43. When the limit of the lost motion connection is reached, however, the head 105 engages the cap 106 and further lifting movement is retarded by the action of the dash pot 104.

The latter is provided with one or more leak ports 107 which may be regulated and adjusted to give a desired timing. After the lapse of a predetermined time, the delaying lifting movement of the core will have proceeded far enough to cause the disc to reachv the contacts 108, 108, bridging the latter and .closing the circuit which moves the main motor switch 72, marking the close of the starting cycle. The magnet 96 being simultaneously deenergized (as hereinafter described), the core 101, by reason of the lost -motion connection, immediately drops? part way, separating the contacts 108 and immediately thereafter again closes the feedmotor-control circuitat the contacts 43, due

Y to the descent of the dash pot piston: To

facilitate the downward movement of the latter, it maybe provided withone or more check valves 109-, herein shown in ball form, and adapted to open to permit a free flow of oil past the piston on the downward movement of'the latter. e When the bridging disc T of the timer engages the contacts 108 a circuit is established through the main switch magnet 73 from the ower line I, first through the switch pushutton 79 and conductor '90, as previously described, thence through the connection 110,

contacts 108, connections 1 11 and 112,-thence net 71, causing thestarting switch 70 to open.

This is accomplished by the bridging switch 113 carried by the switch 72 contact arm 92 to separate the same from the fixed contact 93, thereby breaking the energizing circuit for the ma net 71 and causing the switch 70 to open. The circuit for the tir'nermagnet is simultaneously broken, not only at the contact 93 but also at the contacts 87 and 88, due to the bridging switch 86 therefrom on the, opening of the starting switch 70.

With the closing of the switch 72 an energizing circuit for its magnet is established independently of the timer control circuit b the action of the bridging switch 113 which connects the pivoted contact arm 92 through the stationary contact 114 and conductor 115 with the magnet conductor 112.

The work motor M has now been brought up to speed, the starting 0 cle completed and its switch control circuit t rough the magnet 73permanentl established until such time as thestop pushutton 7.9 may be depressed or the master relay circuit opened. The timer plunger drops back by gravity to its original position, where it again closes the feed-motor-control circuit, placing the latter in position to start the feed motor so far as the-starting of the work motor M is concerned.

The feed motor control circuit passesthrough thetimer switches T of all the Work motors of the group, so that, after "the attempted starting of any one of the work motors'the feed motor starting circuit becomes dead and the feed motor cannot be started until the starting cycle of that work motor has been'completed and until its timer: has

returned to its normal position. If-the feed motor is in operation when the starting of and adapted, when the latter is .closed, to move the pivoted any work motor is attempted it is immedi- I ately cut out of circuit.

From the foregoing it will be seen that the I I depression of the starting button. for any work motor'acts simultaneously with the en- 'ergization ofthe timer and the actuation of the .work-moto'r-starting switch to open the feed motor circuitl' The delayed movement of the timer, following its initial breaking of the feed-motor-control circuit, permits the work motor to be brought up to speed. At

the end of the predetermined time, the timer functions, throwing the main switch 72 and establishing the running connections for the motor, time in turn opening the starting switch 70 and efiecting the deenergization of the timer, which latter in turn is followed by the re-establishment of the feed-motor. control circuit.

are protected against overload due to the pre-.

mature starting of the feed.

In 'Fig. 3 there is shown a simplified circuiting diagram where the control devices, including the switches, switch magnets, push buttons, etc, are designated with reference characters'corresponding to those employed in Fig. 1-, their functional relationship, however, eing the same as that already described in connectlon with Fig. 1.

While I have herein shown and described one specific embodiment and one particular application of my invention, it is to be under stood that extensive deviations may be made from the form herein illustrated and numerous other applications may be made of the same, all without departing from the spirit thereof.

I claim:

1. The combination with a plurality of motors with controlling devices therefor comprising for each motor a magnetically-operated line switch with controlling circuits and primary circuit-changing means, automatic starting devices for each motor comprising a starting resistance, a magnetically-actuated, starting switch controlled by. said primary starting means forconnecting the motor to the line through said starting resistance, a plurality of magnetically-operated timer devices, including one for each motor actuated by the starting of said motor to connect the same to theline independently of the startmg resistance after a predetermined time interval, a motor adapted through its operation to impose a load on said plurality of motors, a magnetically-actuated line switch therefor (in the closure of which depends the operation of said last named motor, a switchcontrolling circuit therefor and means acting through said several timer devices for opening said switch-controlling circuit on the starting of any one of said plurality of motors and for again closing said circiiit only after the lapse of time interval determined by l said timer device.

2. The combination with a plurality of motors of controlling devices includinga magnetically-operated, line switch and automatic starting means for each motor, a plurality of timer means, one for each automatic starting means determining the starting cycle thereof, a device the operation of which is adapted to impose a load on said plurality of motors and means subject to the control of said several timer means for preventing the operation of said device until the timer means for any motor started has marked the completion of starting cycle.

3. The combination with a group of motors including a plurality of motors and another motor the operation of which is adapted to impose a load'on each of said plurality of motors, of a magnetically actuated startin switch with its control device for each of sai plurality of motors for separately and independently connecting each motor to a power line to start the same either separately or in overlapping operation in any desired order or time relation, automatic starting devices for each of said motors to limit the current output until the motor has attained a substanially normal speed, a magnetically actuated starting switch for said other motor and normally operable independentlyof the operation of said plurality of motors, and circuit connections rendered effective during the functioning of anyone or more of said automatic starting devices and controlling the starting switch-for said other motor to prethe vent the operation of said other motorduring control device to'start said other motor and I normally operable independently of theoperation of said plurality of'motors, and

means effective on the starting of any of said plurality of motors to prevent for a limited but substantial time interval during the starting thereof the simultaneous operation of said other motor.

5. The combination with a plurality of motors, each bein provided with a magnetically actuated starting switch and control devices therefor, means for starting the individual motors either separately or in overlapping operation in any desired order or time relation, another motor with its magnetically actuated starting switch and control devices therefor, and automatic means toprevent the operation of said other motor for a substantial-time interval during the'starting of any of said plurality of motors. 6. The combination wit motors of a device the operationof which is adapted to impose a load on any of said plurality 'ofmotors in operation, magnetically actuated starting switches with control devices for separately and independently connecting each of'said plurality of motors to a power line to start the same either separately h a pluralityof i V or in overlapping operation inany desired order and time relation, an automatic starting device for each inotor to set in operation with the actuation'of its starting switch and provided with means to limit the current input until the motor has attained substantially normal speed, and automatic means rendered effective with the actuation of said automatic starting device and efiective during the functioning thereof to prevent simultaneous'operation of said load-imposing device.

7. The combination with a lurality of motors each with its magnetica ly actuated starting switch and control devices, of another motor with its magneticall actuated starting switch and control devices, automatic means for each of said plurality of motors dependent on the startin of its associated motor to prevent for a su stantial time interval during the startin thereof the starting of said other motor, i at rest, or to stop the-same, if running.

8. The combination with a plurality of motors with individual starting devices therefor, of another motor, a plurality of separate timer devices associated, one each with the startingdevice of each of said plurality of motors, means controlled by each of said timer devices dependent on the starting of its said other motor for a substantial time interval during the starting thereof.

9. The combination with a motor having a magnetically actuated starting switch, of a second motor with its magnetically actuated starting switch, automatic starting means for the first motor set in operation with the actu- Station of its starting switch and provided with 'wmeans to limit the current input until the fl inotor has attained substantially normal speed, and. automatic means rendered effective with the actuation of said automatic starting device and effective during the functioning of the starting device of said first motor both to prevent the starting ofsaid second motor, if at rest, and, if in operation, to stop its operation.

10. The combination with a motor, of means for starting the same including a magnetically actuated starting switch, a timer switchassociated therewith, a second motor with means, also including a magnetically actuated switch, for starting the same normally 'opera-ble independently of the 65 starting means for said first motor, and a circuit controllin the starter for the second ,r perative y related to said timer switch to stop the second motor, it running, -'or to prevent its 0 ation, if at rest, during 00 the starting of sai first motor.

11. The combination with a group of motors, including a plurality of motors, and another motor adapted to impose a load on said pluralit of motors, automatic starting to means'inclu ing a magnetically actuatedreassociated motor to prevent the operation of,

tarded movement timer switch for each of said plurality of motors to determine the completion of the starting cycle, means for starting said motors either separately or in overlapping relation in any desired order or time relation, and means-for automatically preventing the operation of said other motor during the starting cycle of any of said plurality of motors, including a controlling circuit" for said other motor controlled by the said several timer switches.

12. The combination with a group of motors, including a plurality of motors, and another motor adapted to impose a load on said plurality of motors, magnetically actuated automatic starting means including magnetically-actuated timer switches, one for each of said plurality of motors, movable to determine the completion of the motor starting cycle, a circuit determining the operative r connection of the other motor to the 'line circuit changing connections controlling said circuit subject to the action of said several timer switches and, in the normal position of the latter, ineffective for preventing the operation of said second motor, means for magnetically actuating each timer switch independently of the other on the initial starting of its respective motor, and retarding devices permitting said switch an initial unretarded movement in its normal position followed by a retarded movement to its cycle determining position, and permitting its return to its normal position at the end of the starting cycle, thereby to act through said circuit changing connections to prevent the operation of said other motor during the starting of any of said plurality of motors.

13. The combination with a group of motors, including a plurality of motors, and another motor adapted to impose a load on each of said plurality of motors, starting means for each of said motors, timing means said plurality of motors, individual starting 1 devices for each of said group of motors normally operable each to start its motor independently of the operation of the remaining motors of the group, and means, efi'ective through the act of starting any of said plurality of motors to prevent the operation of said'otlier motor for a substantial time interval during the starting of the aforesaid one of the lurality of motors.

15. he combination with a plurality of I motors, of another motor, each having starting devices comprising a magnetically actuated starting switch, primary circuit controlling devices for separately and independently connecting each of said motors to a power line to start the same in any desired order, and automatic means efiective through the act of starting any of said plurality of motors to pr vent the starting of said other motor, if at rest, or, if in operation, to stop its operation, for a substantial time interval following the starting of any of said plu rality of motors.

16. The combination with a motor having starting means comprising a magnetically actuated starting switch and controlling devices therofor, of a second motor having starting means also comprising a magnetically actuated starting switch and controlling devices therefor, a timer device associated with the starting switch of said first motor, and automatic means effective through the act of starting said first motor for preventing the starting of said other motor, if at rest, or, if in operation, to stop its operation,

for a substantial time interval followingthe' starting of said first motor. I

17 The combination with a motor having automatic starting means, including a magnetically-actuated, retarded-movement timer switch to determine the completion of the a starting cycle, of a second motor, and means efi'ective only during the starting cycle of said operative during the starting cycle of said first motor for automatically stopping said second motor it running, or for preventing, its operation if at rest, said means mcludmg a-controlling circuit for the second motor having circuit changing devices actuated on the initial movement of said timer switch to change said controlling circuit and to reestablish the same only on the completion of its retarded movement.

18. The combination with a motor having starting means, of a second motor also having its starting means, and means associated with the starting means of said first motor, and effective for a substantial timetinterval during the starting cycle of said first motor,

both to prevent'the starting of such second motor if at rest, and, if in operation, to stop its operation, said last named means being first motor.

19. The combination with a motor having a magnetically actuated starting switch and a control device therefor, of automatic starting means set in operation with the actuation of its starting switch and provided with starting of said first motor, both to prevent the starting of said second motor, if atrest,

a JoHN B. WIARD.

law 

